Your neighbor wants permanent access to your land. Your prescriptive easement defense starts with evidence—not a fence. Get the facts wrong, and your driveway could become someone else’s legal access route.
Prescriptive easement defense: What defeats a California claim?
In California, the claimant must prove five years of open, visible, continuous, uninterrupted use without permission and under a claimed right. Repeated use alone is not enough.
Start with a timeline and a map. Test these facts:
- Permission: Preserve texts, emails, and access agreements. Authorized use is not adverse use. Silence or friendliness alone does not establish permission.
- Timing: Identify when use began and any meaningful interruptions. Seasonal use can qualify; a temporary pause may not defeat continuity. A property sale does not automatically restart the clock.
- Visibility: Hidden activity may undermine the claim, even though the owner need not witness every trip.
- Scope: Pin down the route, width, frequency, and purpose. Walking access does not automatically establish commercial truck access.
Paying property taxes is not your answer. A prescriptive easement generally does not require the claimant to pay them.
Permission signs require specific language and placement: at each entrance or no more than 200 feet apart along the boundary. An ordinary “No Trespassing” sign is not necessarily a substitute. New signs or permission do not automatically erase rights already established.
Before blocking access, preserve photographs, original messages, witness information, deeds, and existing agreements. An obstruction could trigger an injunction or damages if access rights already exist.
Served with a lawsuit? A standard California civil summons generally requires a written response within 30 days after service. Confirm your deadline immediately; missing it can lead to default.
A California civil litigation attorney can challenge the claim’s existence or narrow its scope. Even if some access is established, the evidence may not support everything demanded.
Talk to a California business attorney
Protect your access rights before a missed deadline costs you leverage. Schedule a free consultation or call (424) 603-8888.
This article is attorney advertising and provides general information only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney–client relationship. The law changes, and this article reflects the law as of its publication date. Every situation is different — contact us to discuss how the law applies to your exact circumstances. See our full disclaimer.

